top of page
Search

VLOOKUP vs. XLOOKUP vs. INDEX-MATCH: Which One Deserves Your Time in 2025?


Banner showing the topic.

VLOOKUP vs. XLOOKUP vs. INDEX-MATCH: Which One Deserves Your Time in 2025?

Let me guess—you’ve probably heard of VLOOKUP, maybe even wrestled with it at some point, and now suddenly everyone’s talking about XLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH like they're Excel’s cool new superheroes.



But which one is actually worth your time in 2025? And more importantly, which one will make your daily work easier, faster, and let’s be honest—make you look like an Excel pro in your office (or on Zoom)?


Let’s break it all down in a way that’s simple, practical, and fun—with zero fluff and all real-world value. This isn’t just about learning Excel—it’s about learning it smart.


Why Lookup Functions Even Matter

Before we jump into the vs. battle, let’s pause for a second. Lookup functions are the unsung heroes of everyday Excel work. They help you:

  • Pull a product price from a database

  • Match employee names to IDs

  • Grab email IDs from a lead list

  • Connect data across sheets and files

… all without manually scrolling, searching, or copy-pasting. In short, they save hours.



They’re a must-know, whether you're a student, analyst, marketer, freelancer, or founder.

And in 2025, with all the noise around AI, automation, and dashboards, knowing the right lookup function is still a golden skill that gives you control over your data.


VLOOKUP: The Friendly Dinosaur

VLOOKUP’s been around forever. If Excel functions were like old Nokia phones, VLOOKUP is the 3310—solid, reliable, and it still works. But let’s be honest, it’s showing its age.


Syntax: =VLOOKUP(lookup_value, table_array, col_index_num, [range_lookup])


Pros:

  • Easy to learn

  • Works great for small, structured tables

  • Still found in 90% of corporate Excel files

Cons:

  • Can’t look to the left

  • Breaks if you move columns

  • Slows down with large datasets


Real Use Case: You’re trying to pull sales figures from a product list. Works well—as long as your key column is on the left.


But here’s the catch: If someone inserts a column, VLOOKUP might suddenly pull the wrong data. That’s not ideal when you’re preparing a client report due in 10 minutes.


INDEX + MATCH: The Power Couple

Now here comes the combo that Excel veterans swear by. INDEX gives you a value, MATCH tells you where to look. Together, they’re like a well-coordinated dance team.


Syntax: =INDEX(return_range, MATCH(lookup_value, lookup_range, 0))


Pros:

  • Can look in any direction (left, right, up, down)

  • Doesn’t break with column changes

  • Handles large data better than VLOOKUP

Cons:

  • Slight learning curve

  • Not as readable for Excel beginners

VLOOKUP vs. XLOOKUP vs. INDEX-MATCH: Which One Deserves Your Time in 2025?

Real Use Case: You’re pulling employee names from a list where IDs are on the right of the names. VLOOKUP can’t do this—but INDEX-MATCH can, effortlessly.

It’s a great option if you work with dynamic data and need reliability.


XLOOKUP: The Smartest Lookup Yet


Welcome to Excel 365’s biggest glow-up. XLOOKUP is what happens when Microsoft listens to years of user complaints and finally creates the lookup function we always wanted.

Syntax: =XLOOKUP(lookup_value, lookup_array, return_array, [if_not_found], [match_mode], [search_mode])


Pros:

  • Looks both left and right

  • Returns default values if nothing is found

  • Cleaner syntax, easier to read

  • Can replace both VLOOKUP and HLOOKUP

Cons:

  • Only available in Excel 365 and Excel 2021+

  • May not work in files shared with users on older versions


Real Use Case: You’re creating a live sales dashboard that updates in real time. You need something flexible, future-ready, and readable—XLOOKUP nails it.

It’s faster, cleaner, and built for how we work with data in 2025.


Visual Comparison – At a Glance

Feature

VLOOKUP

INDEX+MATCH

XLOOKUP

Lookup Left?

❌

✅

✅

Easy to Learn?

✅

❌

✅

Stable with Data Changes?

❌

✅

✅

Available in All Excel Versions?

✅

✅

❌

Supports Custom "Not Found" Message?

❌

❌

✅

Handles Large Data Well?

❌

✅

✅


So, Which One Should You Learn?

✅ If you’re just getting started: Learn VLOOKUP for basics, then move on quickly.

✅ If you want flexibility and reliability: Master INDEX + MATCH.

✅ If you’re using Excel 365/2021: Go all-in with XLOOKUP—it’s the future.


If you work with data regularly, knowing all three gives you an edge. You’ll always have the right tool for the job.


Personal Tip: How I Switched to XLOOKUP and Never Looked Back


When I first learned XLOOKUP, I thought—“Okay, just another fancy update.” But within two weeks, I found myself using it in 90% of my files.


Why?

  • Easier syntax means faster work

  • No more counting columns (thank god)

  • Built-in error handling saved hours in client reports

Switching to XLOOKUP felt like switching from a bicycle to a scooter. Same job—just way faster.


Final Thoughts: Lookup Functions Still Matter in the Age of AI

Even with all the talk of AI tools and automation, your fundamentals matter. Knowing how to use lookup functions isn’t outdated—it’s essential. These are the skills that make you dependable, efficient, and self-reliant at work.


If you're someone who wants to master Excel—not just learn it—this is your playground.

And hey, if this helped even a bit, don’t forget to connect with me or follow Excel Wizardd for more real-world Excel, VBA, and automation magic.


Let’s make Excel feel less like a chore and more like a superpower.


🧠 Weekly Boost from Excel WizarddReal Excel skills. Zero fluff. Follow @excelwizardd on Instagram and LinkedIn for more.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet
Add a rating
bottom of page